Vincent van Gogh — Bipolar, Epilepsy or Absinthe? The Evidence
Maybe you know the pattern from the inside. Weeks of work pour out of you, you barely sleep, and everything looks bright. Then the drop comes, and the person who was flying a fortnight ago can hardly get out of bed. Someone has probably said "you are such an artist" as if the swings came free with the talent. You may have wondered whether that is true, or whether it is just a story people tell about creative people.
Vincent van Gogh is the main source of that story. The "tortured genius" who cut off his ear, painted The Starry Night in an asylum and died at 37 has become shorthand for the idea that madness and brilliance are linked.
In 2016, the Van Gogh Museum in Amsterdam tried to settle what was actually wrong with him. It brought together medical specialists and art historians and asked them to test every serious diagnosis against the evidence. The result was more honest than a single label, and more useful too.
What happened at the 2016 Van Gogh Museum expert meeting
The meeting ran alongside the museum's 2016 exhibition On the Verge of Insanity: Van Gogh and His Illness. Psychiatrists, neurologists and other physicians weighed the pros and cons of each diagnosis proposed so far. Van Gogh specialists then checked whether those diagnoses rested on facts in the record or on legend. The conclusions were presented at a public symposium the next day.
The headline finding was a refusal to give a headline. Louis van Tilborgh, the museum's senior researcher, told reporters:
"We've come to the conclusion that it's impossible to draw a final conclusion about his illness."
Van Tilborgh said Van Gogh may have had a borderline or bipolar personality before the ear incident. He pointed to a combination of triggers for the breakdown in Arles, including heavy drinking, poor eating and his deteriorating relationship with Paul Gauguin.
The museum promised a full publication of the specialists' findings. As the art historian Martin Bailey reported in The Art Newspaper in 2020, agreeing on a text proved difficult, and the joint report had not appeared. Instead, four of the specialists published their own analysis, which is now the most detailed modern account.
What actually happened to Van Gogh's ear
Before weighing diagnoses, it helps to separate fact from myth. On 23 December 1888, after a confrontation with Gauguin in Arles, Van Gogh cut off his left ear with a razor. He wrapped it and took it to a brothel, where he handed it to a young woman named Gabrielle.
For decades, many accounts claimed he removed only the lobe. The independent researcher Bernadette Murphy challenged that. In the archive of the novelist Irving Stone at the University of California, Berkeley, she found a 1930 letter from Félix Rey, the young doctor who treated Van Gogh in Arles. It includes a sketch showing the cut, with a note that "the ear was cut off with a razor" along a dotted line that removes almost the whole ear.
Not everyone accepts it. The painter Paul Signac, who visited soon afterwards, wrote of the lobe rather than the whole ear. But the museum displayed Rey's drawing in 2016, and the whole-ear account is now the more widely accepted one.
The case for bipolar disorder
The strongest single candidate is a mood disorder. In 2020, the psychiatrists Willem Nolen, Erwin van Meekeren and Willem van Tilburg and the neurologist Piet Voskuil, all participants in the museum meeting, published "New vision on the mental problems of Vincent van Gogh" in the International Journal of Bipolar Disorders.
They worked through every proposed diagnosis using structured diagnostic interviews, with three art historians who knew the letters well answering the questions on Van Gogh's behalf. Their conclusion was that he most likely had a probably bipolar mood disorder with traits of borderline personality disorder. This vulnerability was present from early adulthood.
The letters support a long history of mood swings. His father wrote that Vincent "always has the inclination to melancholy." Vincent himself described depression as being "bound hand and foot, lying in a deep, dark pit, powerless to do anything." At other times he wrote of "a terrible clarity of mind" and of staying up three nights in a row to paint.
But the authors did not stop at bipolar disorder. They argued it was made worse by alcohol dependence and malnutrition. Of the episodes after the ear incident, they judged two to be likely deliria caused by alcohol withdrawal, followed by severe depressions, at least one of them psychotic.
Lead author Nolen admitted the limits of the work, saying that "our article certainly won't be the last on Van Gogh's illnesses." Voskuil acknowledged that the expert discussions had "not resulted in enough consensus to express final conclusions."
Did Van Gogh have epilepsy
Epilepsy is not a modern invention. It was the diagnosis of the doctors who actually treated him. Félix Rey in Arles suggested it, and Théophile Peyron, the director of the asylum at Saint-Rémy, wrote of "attacks of epilepsy, separated by long intervals."
Nolen and colleagues think these doctors meant what 19th-century French medicine called masked epilepsy, close to what we now call focal temporal lobe epilepsy. That kind of seizure can cause confusion, odd perceptions and abrupt changes in behaviour without full convulsions.
The theory has serious backers. In 1956, the French neurologist Henri Gastaut argued for temporal lobe epilepsy, and in 2002 the psychiatrist Dietrich Blumer revisited the case in the American Journal of Psychiatry. Blumer largely confirmed the epilepsy diagnosis but noted that "there are clearly bipolar aspects to his history."
The objection is the pattern of the crises. The biochemist Wilfred Arnold has argued that their timing and duration, often lasting weeks, do not fit typical complex partial seizures. With no EEG or brain imaging available, the 2020 authors concluded that temporal lobe epilepsy "cannot be excluded" as an additional condition, which is a long way from proven.
Was absinthe to blame for Van Gogh's illness
Absinthe is the most romantic theory and the weakest. The legend holds that the drink's wormwood compound, thujone, poisoned Van Gogh's brain, caused hallucinations and even turned his world yellow.
The chemistry does not support it. In 2008, a team led by the food chemist Dirk Lachenmeier analysed sealed bottles of pre-ban absinthe and found thujone levels far too low to cause the effects attributed to it, roughly in line with modern absinthe. The 2020 review rejected thujone poisoning for the same reason.
Alcohol itself is another matter. Absinthe was typically 50 to 70 per cent alcohol, and the letters show Van Gogh drinking heavily and smoking hard in Paris and Arles, often instead of eating. He described the urge "to stun oneself by taking a stiff drink or smoking very heavily." The problem was not a magic ingredient. It was ordinary alcohol, in large amounts, on an empty stomach, in a man already vulnerable.
Even here, experts disagree. Martin Bailey has challenged the withdrawal theory, noting that the Saint-Rémy asylum allowed Van Gogh double the usual wine ration, about half a litre a day. If he never fully stopped drinking, withdrawal becomes harder to blame for his later crises.
The theories that fell apart
Van Gogh has attracted a long list of other diagnoses. Most have not survived scrutiny.
Schizophrenia. Nolen and colleagues rejected it because he had no psychotic symptoms before 35, none between episodes, and none of the withdrawal and flatness typical of the condition.
Ménière's disease. In 1990, the otologist I. Kaufman Arenberg and colleagues argued in JAMA that Van Gogh had this inner-ear disorder. The 2020 review found nothing in the sources to support it.
Acute intermittent porphyria. Loftus and Arnold proposed this rare metabolic disorder in the BMJ in 1991. It is extremely rare, and no affected family members are known.
Digitalis and yellow vision. In 1981, the surgeon Thomas C. Lee suggested in JAMA that the foxglove drug digitalis tinted Van Gogh's vision yellow. There is no evidence he was ever prescribed it, and he favoured yellow before any possible exposure. Arnold has called the idea a blatant example of unsupported speculation.
The pattern is familiar from our look at Charles Darwin's 49 proposed diagnoses. A dramatic life invites dramatic explanations, and each specialist tends to find their own speciality in the record.
Did mental illness make Van Gogh a great painter
This is where the popular story goes most wrong. Van Gogh did not paint in the grip of his crises. The museum notes that he could not work during attacks and was not allowed to. Nolen and colleagues found that his mental state is visible in only a handful of paintings.
What he did was paint between crises, and he saw work as a way of holding himself together. In September 1889 he wrote to his brother Theo that "work distracts me infinitely better than anything else." A few days later he added that work in the intervals "can go on as usual, and it may even be my remedy." In roughly a year at Saint-Rémy he produced around 150 paintings.
Population research tells a similar, more measured story. Simon Kyaga and colleagues at the Karolinska Institute followed more than a million people in Swedish registers. People with bipolar disorder were over-represented in creative professions, but people in creative work overall were not more likely to have most psychiatric conditions. Writers were the main exception.
A link at the population level is not the same as illness causing genius. Van Gogh's discipline, training and relentless practice were what turned his vision into paintings. We explore the wider evidence in Creativity and Neurodivergence — What Research Shows.
Van Gogh through a dimensional lens
The expert meeting failed to agree on a label. But you do not need a label to see the shape of Van Gogh's mind. Three of CognitionType's seven dimensions describe his pattern more usefully than any single diagnosis.
Emotional regulation. This is the centre of his story. His moods swung widely, and transitions hit him hard: leaving jobs, leaving home, Gauguin's arrival and threatened departure, Theo's marriage and the birth of Theo's son. The breakdown in Arles came at the peak of an intense, fraught partnership. His later fear of the next attack added a second layer of stress on top of the first.
Attention and rhythm. Van Gogh's daily rhythms were chaotic in Arles. He went nights without sleep, skipped meals for coffee, tobacco and alcohol, and worked "like one truly possessed." Sleep loss and poor nutrition are known to destabilise mood, and his recoveries tended to come when life became more ordered, as it did in the routine of the asylum.
Expression and output. Here he was exceptionally strong. Around 820 of his letters survive, and they are vivid, precise and self-aware. He could describe his own depression, analyse colour theory and plan a painting in the same page. That fluency helped him make sense of his experience, and it gave later researchers the evidence they still argue over.
Seen this way, Van Gogh was not one diagnosis. He was a person with fragile mood regulation and chaotic daily rhythms, made worse by alcohol and hunger, who also had a powerful ability to turn experience into words and images. That description explains more than "mad genius," and it is closer to what the experts actually found. It is the same case we make in The Dimensional Model — Why Labels Miss the Point.
The verdict on Van Gogh — what the evidence supports
- Van Gogh had bipolar disorder: The leading hypothesis, probably alongside borderline personality traits. Well supported by the letters, but not certain.
- Van Gogh had epilepsy: It was his own doctors' diagnosis and is still possible as an additional condition. The pattern of his crises makes it unlikely to be the whole story.
- Absinthe made him mad: Not supported. Thujone levels were too low. Heavy alcohol use, however, probably made everything worse.
- Ménière's, porphyria, digitalis or schizophrenia: Weakly supported or rejected by the most recent expert review.
- His illness produced his art: Not supported. He painted between crises, not during them, and saw work as a remedy.
What you can do with this
If Van Gogh's story feels close to home, a few lessons from it are worth taking seriously.
- Treat mood swings as information, not identity. Big swings in energy and mood are not the price of being creative. They are worth telling a doctor about, especially if they come with weeks of reduced sleep or deep lows.
- Watch the basics. Van Gogh's worst periods came with little sleep, little food and a lot of alcohol. These are not minor details. They are some of the most reliable ways to destabilise a vulnerable mood.
- Protect your rhythm. Stable sleep, meals and routine helped Van Gogh recover. They work as foundations for anyone whose mood is easily knocked off balance.
- Use your strengths to process. Writing, making and talking things through gave Van Gogh a way to understand what was happening to him. If expression comes easily to you, use it.
- Map your profile, not just your symptoms. CognitionType is a useful tool for understanding your own cognitive profile, including dimensions like emotional regulation, attention and rhythm, and expression and output. It can give you clearer language to bring to a professional, and it complements a formal assessment rather than replacing one.
Van Gogh did not need a diagnosis to keep working. But he deserved better care than the 19th century could offer, and so do you. The real lesson of the 2016 meeting is not that his mind was unknowable. It is that a mind is better understood as a set of strengths and pressures than as a single word.
CognitionType is an informational assessment, not a clinical diagnosis. If you are experiencing significant mood swings, low mood or thoughts of self-harm, please seek a formal evaluation from a qualified professional, or contact a crisis line in your country if you need help now.